Sunday, February 18, 2007

Pop Quiz, Hotshot

Ok, break out your imagination berets, kiddies. Moral dilemma-a-coming up.

You are an army officer, and it is wartime. You have been disconnected from any of your men, superior or subordinate. You are lost in the battlefield with no contact, radio or otherwise, with any friendly combatants. However, in your struggles to survive, you have managed to meet up with and stick with five or six other soldiers, all standard privates or corporals, with very little to no training in navigation or leadership whatsoever. They were stranded, hiding out in a mismatch of foxholes and dugouts, with no idea what to do or where to go. You know none of this ragtag bunch of troops, but being the highest in rank, you are now their leader. Their ticket to survival. As you trek across the wartorn landscape, your motley crew comes under assault. Shouting out quick orders, you pull your newfound buddies into a large crater, one that must've been made by a piece of artillery. It is deep, with a high lip towards your attackers: perfect cover. Your troops hit the side and begin to return fire. Hanging back a little from the firing line, you gauge the action in order to be able to make the best use of the soldiers under your command; you want to win this engagement, but most of all, you want to survive. All of a sudden, there is major problem.

A grenade has been tossed right into your position. Your men miss it, but you see it fly in. From your training, you know it is close enough to render all inhabitants of the crater dead or dying upon explosion. You have less than a second to act. You have three options.
1. Die, along with all your troops.
2. Throw yourself upon the grenade. Your training has also taught you that if the explosion is muffled by a human body, there is an extremely high likelihood that any others within a normal "dead zone" proximity will survive.
3. Grab the nearest soldier, whoever he or she may be, and throw them on the grenade, sacrificing them for the others.

If you choose option 1, you are all dead. If you choose option 2, you are dead, and this bunch of soldiers who were relying on you to survive are left all alone, nobody to lead them. They will likely be either killed or captured without a competent officer to lead them. Lost, confused and with no idea, you may have only spared their lives temporarily. If you choose 3, you are able to lead the soldiers onwards, possibly to survival, but at the expense of one of the group. His or her blood will be on your hands: for good or bad, you ended their life. This soldier, who you knew nothing about, will have their life, their dreams, their hopes, their loves all ended with your action of leadership.

What do you do? For my Christian friends out there, take into account your faith. What do you think God would have you do?

-Sean-

7 comments:

Ponyb said...

i hate this new Google/Blogger look. my links and archives sidebar looks like annoying. gargh.

Missus Upton said...

wow, thats kind of a tough one.

I definately wouldn't chose the first option, that's of no use to anyone. so second or third...

lol, is it possible to grab the grenade and throw it back?? =P

SuperTiph said...

This is why I decided against joining the army. Option 1 means that there are the most immediate casualties. Theoretically it's worse than option 3 because you've ended many lives, but since you've also ended your own you don't have to live with blood on your hands. Option 2 is the most heroic it would appear, but where does it leave the other soldiers? Aren't you once again causing casualties, although not immediately?
Option 3 leaves the least people harmed, but you do end the life of a soldier, someone you didn't know. Still, they knew when they joined the army that the risks they were taking, and that going to war meant they may not come home.

I don't know which one I'd choose, because I think of Jesus saying, "Greater love has no man than he who lays his life down for his friends." But I don't know. I really just don't know.

Good food for thought, though. Which did you choose Sean@?

Tigers in a Cheese Song

Ponyb said...

i first read this scenario when i was in grade 10. up until now, i had no idea what course of action i would take, no matter how much i thought upon the question. but now, i think i know what i would do. i cannot say for sure, and i will never know unless i am in this actual situation, which i pray that i never am.

i would like to believe that i would take option 2. i say this because although it renders me unable to be of any further leadership ability to my men, i would be giving all of them a shot at survival, no matter how minimal it may be. war is hell, but if there's even the slightest possibility of hope, then there is hope enough for them to survive.

being one who is currently considering various options in the defence force, leadership as an officer is one of those things that require one to possibly make decisions like this. it freaks me out to imagine myself in this position, yet it challenges me to find the answer.

so yes, i believe that i would take option 2, taking onboard the hope for my soldiers to be able to survive and fight on their own.

"Courage only comes when you are scared to death" - Anon.

Missus Upton said...

yeah, you have a good point there ponyboy.

Actually, thats exactly what Jesus did for us.

There was never any guarantee that his death would lead us to salvation, but there was hope. It didn't matter how faint that hope was, he threw himself on that grenade and took the full blast himself, leaving us to fight on. Through him dying, he provided an escape for us. Whether or not we took that escape was up to us...

The way i see it, we can look at what Jesus, our herioc leader, did to provide us an opportunity, and do one of four things. We can choose to totally ignore it and act like nothing happened at all, We can stand there in total shock and in turn, forfeit our lives to the approaching enemy, We can just throw our lives away, or we can take the opportunity he left us. Stand and fight. Fight for our lives and never surrender till the end.

Personally, I know which option I wanna take.

Missus Upton said...

Hmm, though Jesus' story did end a bit differently, cause he didn't leave us to fend for ourselves...

so maybe not EXACTLY what jesus did...

Sara said...

Well since i havent visited here for ages I dont get to explain why... pony pretty much did it for me... but my answer is definately b/2 or whatever it is. Im not at all scared of dying but i dont know about those other soldiers.